Time to think
One of you told me the end-of-round discards don't give you enough time to think. You were right, but when I went looking the problem wasn't really that the timer was short.
Before touching a number I went and read how other card games do this. Runeterra banks the seconds you didn't spend. Master Duel hands you a 300-second pool and tops it up at the start of every turn. Arena lets you earn extensions by playing fast. Hexarchy adds four seconds to your turn for every card you draw. Then I looked at ours: four fixed windows, no bank, no pool, and the same thirty seconds for "yes or no?" as for "discard up to three of these eight, then draw cards equal to their total heart value."
Meanwhile committing your card — one of five, whole board sitting in front of you, nothing on it you haven't already read — gets two full minutes.
So the easiest decision in the game had four times the clock of the hardest one. That's the actual bug. Thirty seconds isn't too short for a yes or no. It's ridiculous for a subset problem across your entire hand.
How it works now
A choice gets thirty seconds, plus five more for every card or option sitting in front of you, up to ninety. That's the whole rule. What it means in practice:
A yes or no is still thirty seconds. There's no list to get through — the question is in the ability text you're already looking at and the answer is one of two buttons. Nothing to compare, so nothing to add.
Discarding three out of a hand of eight is now seventy. It was thirty.
Reordering the top four of your deck is now fifty. Also was thirty.
The bit I went back and forth on: that middle one counts the eight, not the three. Discard-two-of- eight and discard-three-of-eight get the same clock, because the expensive part is reading eight cards and working out which ones you can live without. Tapping the third one is free. So it's how many cards you're choosing between that buys you time, not how many you end up giving up.
Ninety is the ceiling. You hit it at twelve cards or more, and it stays under the two-minute commit on purpose — I didn't want to solve this by flipping the problem round the other way.
Nothing in the game got a shorter clock than it had. That felt like the one rule I wasn't allowed to break while fixing a complaint about not having enough time.
What's still wrong
There's no bank and no pool. If you commit in four seconds you throw away the other hundred and sixteen, and when the hard discard turns up two steps later you get the base window and nothing else. Every other digital card game I looked at carries unspent time forward somehow. We carry none of it.
That's the real fix, and it's a much bigger job — the server, the protocol, and the clock on both clients. I'd rather find out whether this is enough first. So tell me if it isn't.
— Gabe