Digital gets equal billing
Yesterday's shop cards opened with the parts of a printed deck — the cards, a tuck box, a rulebook — and left the digital copy as one small line underneath. Which told you, before you'd decided anything, that this was a shop for printed decks and the $4.99 was an afterthought. That's not what I want the page to say.
So the card leads with the actual question now. Two tiles the same size: Printed + digital and Digital. The printed one is still ticked when the page loads, because that's what most people are here for and a shop grid shouldn't need a tap before Add to cart does anything. But its parts are folded away behind a line that says Add a tuck box or rulebook. Open that, or click the printed tile, and the switches appear — and the price on the tile counts up as you flip them: $14.59, then $20.61 with the box, then $23.44 with the rulebook.
Pick Digital and the parts aren't there at all, because they've got nothing to do with what you're buying.
I went back and forth on whether to fold them at all. Hiding an upsell is usually how you stop selling it. But the alternative was a card whose opening statement is the anatomy of a cardboard box, and a line that names the thing and opens in one tap isn't really hidden.
The one deck that doesn't offer the choice is Sentient, because its digital cards are free to everybody — the printed copy is the only thing there is to buy.
The ordering here has been a bit of a pendulum: 2.66 cut the card to two choices, 2.70 put the parts on it, 2.71 puts the parts back behind the choice. I think this is where it lands. The question that changes the most — a thing in the post, or cards in the app tonight — gets asked first. The question that changes six dollars is one tap underneath it.
— Gabe